In a lot of machine shops, quoting is a spreadsheet, a pile of past jobs, and the judgment of one estimator who has done it for years. It works, mostly. Quotes take days, two people quoting the same part come up with two different numbers, and when the estimator is out, quoting stops.
Shop owners usually go looking for machine shop quoting software at that point, and that's reasonable. But no software can quote like your estimator until somebody writes down what your estimator actually does, and that step is worth doing before you look at a single product.
The rules nobody wrote down
Ask an experienced estimator how they price a job and you will usually hear "it depends." It does depend, on rules they apply without thinking about them anymore. Here are some examples of what those rules look like, so you know what to listen for in your own shop:
- Setup cost that depends on what ran on the machine before, so a part quoted after a similar job comes in lower than the same part quoted cold.
- Material bought one way and charged another, like full bars or sheets bought but only the length used charged, plus a drop that may or may not get used.
- A minimum charge, so a quantity of two isn't quoted as a fraction of a quantity of fifty.
- Quantity breaks that aren't a straight line.
- Customers on contract pricing, or customers who always get a little off because of how much they send.
- Outside work like plating, anodizing or heat treat, marked up a certain way, with time added for the trip.
- Expedited jobs, tight tolerances and difficult finishes that each bump the price by a rule of thumb.
None of that is unusual on its own. What's unusual is the exact combination in your shop, and that combination is the thing a quoting product either has room for or doesn't.
How we get the rules out of one head
When a shop asks us about quoting, we start the same way every time. We sit with the estimator and quote a handful of real jobs together, out loud. They price the job the way they always would, and we ask why at every step. Every "well, for this customer we" is a rule, and every "unless it's" is another one.
The estimator's judgment doesn't go away in this process. It gets written down, which means it can be checked, taught to someone else, and turned into software if that's where it ends up.
What to do with the list
Once the rules are written down, you have three good options, and the list makes all three easier:
- Take it shopping. Hand the list to quoting software vendors and ask them to quote one of your real jobs in a demo, with your rules. A product that handles your list is worth buying, and one that can't will show it fast.
- Lock down the spreadsheet. If you aren't ready for software, put the rules into one shared spreadsheet with the formulas protected, so the second person quoting gets the same answer as the first.
- Build the part that's yours. If the rules that decide whether a job makes money are the ones no product supports, a custom quoting tool can hold them and read costs from the ERP you already have. We wrote about that choice in buy it, or build the part that's yours.
Why it's worth doing even if you never buy software
A shop whose pricing lives in one person's head is one retirement, one illness or one job offer away from guessing. Writing the rules down protects you from that, and it gives you something to train a second estimator from.
It matters when you sell, too. We built a custom ERP for a plastic extrusion manufacturer that brought quotes, work orders, material usage and shipment status into one place that management could actually see. When that company was sold, the clean historical data strengthened its sale valuation. The full case study is here.
If you're still sorting out what you need, it might help to read estimating vs. quoting software first, since a lot of machine shops have one of those problems and not the other.
If quoting in your shop stops when one person is out, we're glad to sit down with your estimator and get the rules written down. Reach out here or call (507) 388-4748.
Using an AI assistant? It can send this inquiry for you. How that works.